
American Airlines and Delta Air Lines said they will remove their codes from AeroMexico and Mexicana flights respectively following the US FAA's downgrading late Friday of Mexico's safety rating from a Category 1 to Category 2.
FAA said that Mexico is "not in compliance with international safety standards set by the International Civil Aviation Organization," noting that it reached the conclusion "following an assessment of the country’s civil aviation authority." The downgrade means Mexican airlines are disallowed from launching new service to the US and from codesharing with US airlines. Existing service by Mexican airlines to/from US airports can continue.
Mexico's Communications and Transport Dept. issued a statement to the Associated Press saying the downgrade was owing "exclusively to administrative and organizational matters…The FAA measure does not imply any decline in the safety of civil aviation in Mexico. Mexico's airlines are safe and will continue to offer high quality service, comparable to the highest international standards."
FAA did not specify what lapse warranted the downgrade. "While Mexico has been responsive to the FAA’s findings and has made significant improvements in recent months, it was unable to fully comply with all of the international safety standards," the agency said, adding that "Mexico continues to make progress. The FAA is committed to working closely with the Mexican government and providing technical assistance to help Mexico regain its Category 1 rating."
FAA said that a Category 2 rating "means a country either lacks laws or regulations necessary to oversee air carriers in accordance with international standards, or that its civil aviation authority...is deficient in one or more areas, such as technical expertise, trained personnel, record-keeping or inspection procedures."
The downgrade provided yet another challenge for Mexicana, which had already conceded ahead of FAA's action Friday that it faced a "difficult" financial situation and was "analyzing all options and resources." The heads of the airline's pilot and flight attendant unions said management approached them regarding severe concessions, including hundreds of layoffs, and had issued an Aug. 9 deadline for reaching an accord on concessionary labor contracts. According to Reuters, CEO Manuel Borja told Mexican radio that without major concessions from its employees, "the company is no longer viable."
Lizette Clavel, secretary general of the Asociacion Sindical de Sobrecargos de Aviacion flight attendants union, told Bloomberg that the cabin crew workers "want guarantees that the airline will keep operating." According to multiple media reports, the carrier yesterday suspended service to Sacramento, where it flew four-times weekly from Cabo San Lucas and daily from Guadalajara.
Discuss this news 33
Sad to hear this news,
By KayeSad to hear this news, however I'm not surprised Mexicana has been quietly hiding many things for decades.
Sadly, yet another indication
By LarrySadly, yet another indication of the crumbling infrastructure in Mexico.
Please, don't let MXA become
By OrlandoPlease, don't let MXA become another VARIG!!! Mexicana is a world class airline, new planes, very good level of service/amenities and a long tradition in aviation history. Mexican carriers, (MX/AM) in general have better levels of service, newer fleets and better amenities than any US Major. This is very surprising!!!
You're kidding, right Olando?
By CustomerYou're kidding, right Olando? Phew, thank goodness, for a moment I thought you said MX/AM have better levels of serice than any US Major. Too funny!!
Orlando is sooo right: Just
By Wish MakerOrlando is sooo right:
Just compare the aircraft age and confort and on-board services between AA and MX and you would see the wolrd of difference; some examples:
MX offers, free of charge, even for ALL coach passengers:
Headsets, Beers, spirits and other alcoholic brevages, HOT food, Blankets, pillows, SMILES !
Try to get any of these for free in AA !
A beer is nice to have, but I
By LazarusA beer is nice to have, but I can wait with that. Professional handling of hazmat, clear crew duty regulations and maintenance oversight is a must-have.
Deficiencies on organizaional levels may not be apparent to the average traveller, but at any given time I'd rather fly CO or DL instead of those flying mexican cantinas.
Too funnny ? Let's seee....
By Wish MakerToo funnny ?
Let's seee.... just answer these:
When was the last time you flew MX ?
When was the last time you got FREE hot food, headsets, and alcoholic brevages on board a US major carrier in coach ?
When did you flew in an aircarf of a major US carrier that was younger than your mother ? ...cleaner and better kept ? (maybe that also applies to the crew and their attitude)
Let's be objective guys !
I agree with Olando. Service
By MikeI agree with Olando. Service on MX/AM is superior to any US carrier. Actually there is no service on US carriers other than the actual transportation from A to B. I flew many times on MX: Free Baggage Allowance, Free Hot Meals and Free Beers ! Cheers !
The Mexican carriers indeed
By AnonymousThe Mexican carriers indeed have better service. Ask my clients who have flown them recently. The service is far better than any US carrier.
It is sad about Mexicana, but
By Jim JIt is sad about Mexicana, but even a cursory look at the US airlines' recent earnings reports shows that their profits are based on the additional charges (bagagge, alchoholic drinks, pillows, etc.) and not flying passengers from A to B. Maybe Mexicana should inaugurate these charges to ensure survival.
Guys, the problem is not with
By AnonymousGuys, the problem is not with the MX/AM, the downgrading is to the country. There are big problems with the security in the country. This downgrading affects MX/AM in the business with the code shares with the American carriers. Mexico loose Cat 1 and this imply a lot of things.
This is a ridiclulous
By stuartThis is a ridiclulous situation.When did Mexicana last have an accident? It must have been 35 years ago. The same cannot be said of most of the US carriers. Fly Mexico! It's safer and better!
Guys, Aeromexico and Mexicana
By Canadian living in Mexico.Guys, Aeromexico and Mexicana are far superior to the likes of AA, CO, UA, DL.
Their fleet is more modern (no more MD going around), they still give you something to eat, no charges for seat pre-assignment, free alcohol including tequila, they still treat you as a human being and not cattle.
Why would you think Funjet Vacations would switch from United to Mexicana for their ORDCUN and ORDPVR value flights or Aeromexico for DFWCUN?......not by chance.....
Wake up, US airlines are a disgrace, wake up before it is too late. They should have been let go belly up without goverment, that is, taxpayer money in bailouts (which by the way are typical of socialist countries and used to pay for top exec bonuses.
Now, bring on the heat.......I will continue to smile down here in Mexico, not a perfect country by any means but so much better than what the US media is portraying Mexico to be. Stop Mexico´s unjustified bashing!.
Too many people want Neiman
By AlohajonToo many people want Neiman Marcus and Nordstrom service, but they want to pay Kmart, Walmart, Target prices. Airlines can not stay in business charging below cost fares. Before deregulation in 1978, most of the passengers were wealthy people, business men and woman on company expense accounts, and the military in dress uniforms [not fatigues], and the military flew standby. Now many people can fly, who would not been able to fly in the "old days." So now can you understand why service is not the same as before? Many of the foreign carriers are losing money because they are not charging enough. Over 200 airlines around the world have gone out of business, since 1978. see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_defunct_airlines and then click on each continent. Thank you.
Mexicana needs to charge more
By AlohajonMexicana needs to charge more money, if they want to stay in business. One of the problems in Latin America is the small rich class wants the masses to work for very small wages with little or no benefits. This is why so many people come to the United States of America. This has been going on for several centuries. How much longer is this going to continue?
I agree totally Orlando. This
By AnonymousI agree totally Orlando. This is a political ploy on the part of the FAA that suggests that Mexicana and Aero Mexico do not meet international safety standards. This is NOT the issue... survival of the airline industry in the US is the primary motivation. Its all about dollars. Mexico is suffering the results of US pressure. If only people knew the truth about what goes on behind the closed doors of the FAA!
I see people are more
By MikeI see people are more concerned with free food than safety. Let's be real and realize what the money on US airlines go to. Oversight and Safety. I would rather be safe then drunk and full.
The downgrade is not due to
By EstebanCardenasThe downgrade is not due to "crumbling infrastructure", but rather to insufficient qualified personnel in the government vigilance agency. This can be explained by the extremely fast growth this industry has experienced in Mexico in the last 5 years, with at least 3 new low cost airlines. Another contributing reason MIGHT be the well known culture of corporate corruption in the US. Main carriers in the US have a lot of influence in the FAA, and this decision certainly is of benefit to them. The Sowthwest-Volaris code-share program, which was about to take off, is not possible anymore due to the downgrade. Now the first attempt for an internationally extended low cost network is in a stand-by. After all, it is well known that the FAA has been convinced in the past by extensive lobbying of not downgrading countries like India or Thailand. We all know the accident records of those places. Mexican carriers have comparable and even better safety records than most US carriers.
Dear Mike, How many US
By Canadian living in Mexico.Dear Mike,
How many US airlines have been involved in a crash in the US over the past few years?. How many such incidents have taken place?.
Now, let´s take a look at Mexico....how many?......
Numbers do not lie. You are right, it is more than free food and booze, safety naturally comes in first and here again US airlines are the clear loosers.
Wake up!. Your airports are crumbling, old, decrepit, way beyond crowded, lack of decent facilities (take a look at MIA, not a single decent restaurant where you can eat healthy food, only greasy American food), connecting in the US is close to a nightmare, let alone your immigration officers and their usual warm welcome to the US, etc.
Dear Mike, to Oversight and
By Be fairDear Mike,
to Oversight and Safety? You mean the oversight that almost let the engines fall off B767s, that allowed the roof to fall off on a SW B737, that did not prevent the ATC in Denver to provide the pilots of CO 735 with correct windshear data? Have I heard anything similar from Mexico. Answer is No. The reason for the answer might be lack of Oversight, but the recent history of incidents in the US does not support your claim, that the Oversight in the US is that far better than in Mexico. Cheers.
The service can be better in
By AnonymousThe service can be better in Mexicana but the administration of the company is really poor, why they changed their image painting planes changing logo, uniforms counters etc.? All the cost of this huge change when you have red numbers. Direct formula to Chapt 11
Do you want a CEO like this? not in my company. : (
Fact: I an mexican and a
By AnonymousFact: I an mexican and a pilot here in the USA.
Fact: Mexicana has one of the oldest Aibus fleet in the Americas.
Fact: Mexicana has the fewest owned aircraft fleet for an airline
Fact: Mexico is a country where most everyone in government is corrupt and a counrty that pushes it's own countrymen out of its own counrty to bring US dollars back.
Fact: Stopping ticket sales is only a scare tactic for the pilots/flt. attendants to give up 41% of there monthly pay
Fact: Mexicana will be around
Fact: Year 12 Southwest pilots make $206.00 per flt. hr.........year 12 Mexicana pilot makes less than 1/2 per hr.
Fact: year 3 Southwest pilots make $102.00 per hr.........year 3 Mexicana pilots make an average $43 per hr.
Fact: Mexicana CEO Emilio Romano was named CEO of Mexicana on March 22, 2004. He earned a Law Degree (Suma Cum Laude) from the Escuela Libre de Derecho and an International Law Degree from the City of London Polytechnic. From 1987 to 1994, Romano held various high-level positions within the Mexican Ministry of Finance. He negotiated the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) and the Mexico-United States Tax Treaty, and served as General Director of Revenue Policy and International Fiscal Affairs. He was appointed Mexico's Fiscal Attorney until March 1995.
From 1995 to 1998, he held the position of Vice President of International Operations of Televisa, responsible for all operations outside of Mexico including Fonovisa
Fact: Another mexican crook stealing from the people
I find it absolutely
By reeceI find it absolutely ludicrous when people make remarks about the free food and drinks onboard. When the US carriers OFFERED them, people complained, whinned and were very critical. Now You do not get them.......unless You Pay. And that's the way IT SHOULD BE. I am T-i-r-e-d of You clowns that feel Someone, Somewhere OWES You something ALL The Time. Airlines ARE Transportation. PERIOD.
about my opinion is tha i
By flier1about my opinion is tha i personaly withness that all the mexicana airlines crew member intimidate to any sct or safety inspectors, maybe this is one of the reasons the faa souldnt let any mexicana o aeromexico, to fly on uss airspace, both airlines dont meet the safety standars of the icao . ask atc about how many violation this carriers commit per month, why?because they dont understand the atc instructions. in my opinion if the crew members dont have respect for the mexican safety inspection their atp should be suspended iam proud that the faa is doing good job.
once again for mexicana
By flier1once again for mexicana airlines pilots, who fly gliders, or blenders, it is absurd and unacceptable to belive that an a320, or 319 , and b757 pilot make on salary $216.000 dls. imp[osible not even the us carriers, the only us capitan who makes that money is a b747 pilot or a b777, and airbus a330 but for those pilots the onces fligh gliders it is to much money, no wander mexicana is broke, is not the same to make pesos to make dls. it is good for volaris, ok hnos fisher i will see you on the unemployment office.
pilotos de mexicana, y la
By ateo1pilotos de mexicana, y la prepotencia: veamos como son the prepotentes los tripulantes de mexicana de aviacion. en todos los vuelos internacionales sobre todo los vuelos de denver de los cuales yo fui testigo, cuando el avion aterrizo en los cabos, supuestamente todos los pasajeros deben pasar por aduana o custom todos pero menos los tripulantes ya que estos intimidan a los agentes aduanales, ya quiciera yo hacer lo mismo cuando regreso a los estados unidos, pararia yo en prision, cuando un piloto viaja como pasajero este individuo debe ser tratado como pasajero, pero no es asi. ahora cuando un inspector de seguridad sube a el avion a preguntar por certificados medicos o a revisar el loog book o vitacora, los tripulantes lo sacan a insultos de el avion. es por eso que los procedimientos de mantenimiento, no se lleban a cabo de acuerdo a las FARS o regulaciones de aviacion ya que la gente se atemoriza cuando ven a un piloto de aviacion en mexico.yo en particular sugiero que el control de seguridad de la aviacion en mexico deberia ser parte de el gibierno federal.
I was AMT for Mexicana
By Oscar GonzalezI was AMT for Mexicana Airlines for many years, you can say many things about pilots and flight attendants salaries and our flying cantinas, but not about the maintenance and operational standards. I admit our aviation authority is a bit incompetent and easy to corrupt but our aircraft are maintained with the same or higher standards than in the USA or Europe. The reason is that American and European insurance and leasing companies own most if not all the aircraft we operate and they ask us to keep them under american register and keep them with the highest standards. We have to pay the latino quota, it means to be better than them to be considered at least as good as them.
responding to the amt. yes i
By ateo1responding to the amt. yes i agree with you aabout the maintenance standards, this is only that you know about that but not the sct inspectors, because pilots like the fisher brothers and almost all of the intimadate to the authorities and maintenance personal. i said this because i was a mexicana pilo. on 1989 i had the chance to flight delta airlines, i do flight b767 400 iam capitain and i dont even make $200.000 dls, then how can be posible that a glider or a320 capitan make $216.000 dls a year pluss bonus for different reasons. realy i blame the pilots and the aspa union about the health of mexicana airlines. once again the pilots dig their own grave, it is to late to recover the health of mexicana to late mexicana is dead i feel sorry for many friends who flight for such airline, the chicken of the golden eggs is dying, but no more goberment bail out .very soon non of mexicana planes will flight over us airspace, if they dont comply with the safety standars, i will mist them.
the mexican SCT aeronautic
By ateo1the mexican SCT aeronautic authorities do not have right people to conduct and keep control of the mexican aviation.
the flight crew feels like like gods, they like to intimidate to every budy, ground crew, maintenance personal, federal authorities, and so on. on denver 6 years ago the flight crew
dont want to let an FAA safety inspector, when the inspector ask to see the log book the comments of the pilots on spanish was (this is a mexican registration airplane) except they dont undertand that to be uble to flight over the us airspace they have to comply with the F,A,R,S this is why the fligth crew needs to read all the regulation, and obey any instruction of an FAA. or SCT safety instructions, the mexican inspectors rather then reinforce the regulations the try to avoid the flight crew, because if they try to do teir job the capitais treth them and maybe they will not have a job the next day, why because the director of the SCT is their compadre.on maintenance wise the mechanics do a great job
but olso they try to avoid the flight crew.
I worked for Mexicana for
By navegaI worked for Mexicana for many years and must say this is sad to see. I disagree with comments questioning Mexicana safety in the cockpit or in general maintenance as this is far from the truth. Safety measures of all aspect are highly regarded and followed at Mexicana and yes although many do not accept it, far more than most USA airlines. Their mechanics are top notch as are their pilots and flight attendants.
Having been involved in third party handling or maintenance in the USA, I can say that very few airlines meet their standards and that is why they have their own mechanics in most of their USA destinations.
They are top notch in my book and I wish them well.
The Canadian living in Mexico
By IguanaDC3The Canadian living in Mexico IS a socialist, having been born in 1 such nation filled with them & now residing in another such nation filled with them as he now seems to be. So, he'd know! All blind nationalism aside, to rank a Mexican aircarrier ahead of AA, CO, DL et al --- by & large --- is fully ludicrous & ignorant. Most of you anti-USA writers herein already have an agenda and/or an ulterior bias against ANYthing USA to start with although you're loathe to have the guts to admit it -- you & your spoiled drunk pals.
You know why the American
By Rafael Angel de la TorreYou know why the American Goberment downgraded by FAA to Mexico, because they try to protect his aviation, because the American Aviation are like a ship in the Ocean, deeping, deeping and deeping.
A little late, but I just
By AnonymousA little late, but I just stumbled across this thread. I have to comment on this.
A few basic facts:
First of all, there are a lot of airlines around the world that give much better customer service. Any one that flies international very much knows this is a simple fact.
Customer service is important to customers.
Not all airlines are equal, including the ones in Mexico and the U.S. Some will do all their inspections on time, won't take short cuts, hire qualified people and keep up with their records. Unfortunately some airlines don't and this is where the problem is.
Airlines in the states, have taken some heavy hits from the FAA for breaking the rules. Fines can be in the millions of dollars, and aircraft have been grounded.
The problem is that Mexico's version of the FAA, has NOT been doing their job to make enforce aviation regulations. This opens to door, for major problems. If an aircraft crashes, everyone will want to know why. While the crash site and the data/voice recorders can help, many times it's the maintenance records, that fill in the blanks.
Those records will show who worked on the aircraft, who supervised it, if the people were properly trained, what parts were used and if they were legal parts.
Unfortunately I've personally seen this problem in Mexico. I don't work for the FAA, but do work in the field.
Many of the problems would never be picked up my most of the airlines staff and never by it's customers. If a pilot notices a problem he writes it up in the log book, and expects it to be fixed properly. However he/she has no way of knowing if it's been done right. Good work ethics, and proper supervision from the government is the best defense from bad maintenance practices.
The good news is, that most airlines on both sides of the boarder, to abide the rules are are safe. However it only takes one....
So what's more important, a free beer or knowing that your aircraft is safe?
Post new comment